HealthNutrition

Kombucha and Kefir: Should You or Shouldn’t You?

By September 2, 2015 January 30th, 2018 No Comments


You may have seen versions of these beverages in the supermarket because they’re the latest hot health-food items…but what are they, and are they worth trying?

Kombucha is a type of fermented tea, while kefir is fermented milk (dairy or non-dairy) beverage. Fermented foods (kimchi, sauer kraut, yogurt) contain benefits like probiotics and b-vitamins, but do these drinkable food items also contain those benefits?

Kombucha

Kombucha is super popular right now and is touted as a “miracle agent” by many; I’m not so sure I’d call it miracle material, but it may have a few benefits. Basically, kombucha is made by fermenting tea using a colony of bacteria and yeast. Other ingredients like spirulina or green tea extract might be added, along with flavorings like ginger, lemon or berries.

You can find bottled kombucha in health food stores and larger supermarkets. Because it’s fermented, it has a very small amount of alcohol (less than 1%). Brewing kombucha at home is a fast-growing hobby; you”ll need a “SCOBY”, the bacteria culture starter that looks a little like a silicone pad.

There are lots of health claims around kombucha that have been largely unproven, like cancer prevention, improved liver function and others that have not yet been proven through research. But kombucha does contain probiotics (the same types of healthy bacteria you’ll find in yogurt). Most people should plan to purchase already-prepared Kombucha (like the one above).

On one hand…

  • Probiotics in kombucha may provide added healthy bacteria for the digestive system
  • Contains B-vitamins that are important for energy production
  • In some commercially processed kombucha teas, there may be added ingredients like chlorophyll, spirulina, green tea extracts, chia seeds and more

On the other hand…

  • The jury is out on health claims around kombucha
  • May contain added sugars (some sugar is necessary for fermentation)
  • Some allergic reactions have been reported
  • Contains yeast in the process of making the beverage and therefore would not be compliant with a low-yeast or candida diet
  • Fermented products on the whole may be difficult to digest for some

Kefir

Kefir is a fermented milk beverage that contains rich probiotics and other healthful nutrients. The good news is that like non-dairy yogurts that are being made, kefir also can be made with non-dairy ingredients.

Kefir can be sipped on its own, or incorporated into a smoothie or other recipes. Basically you can use it anywhere you might use yogurt or buttermilk.

On one hand…

  • Source of gut and immune-healthy probiotics
  • Can be made from non-dairy sources like coconut water, sweetened water and coconut milk
  • Rich source of vitamins, minerals and essential amino acids- like B-vitamins, K2, magnesium and phosphorus
  • Research suggests it may help to improve lactose digestion in adults with lactose intolerance
  • Bacteria strains in kefir may help to promote gut health

On the other hand…

  • Contains yeast, which may not work for anyone on a low-candida or yeast diet
  • May contain extra sugars or artificial sweeteners (depending on brand).
  • As with kombucha, take health claims with a grain of salt until more studies are conducted.

While making kombucha at home requires some special equipment, you can make kefir at home with ordinary kitchen supplies. You’ll need starter kefir grains, which can be purchased inexpensively online, or in some health-food stores.

This article was originally written for Reboot with Joe- click here for the original post.